Wind turbine syndrome blamed for mysterious symptoms in. Wind turbine syndrome, i propose, is mediated by the vestibular system by disturbed sensory input to eyes, inner ears, and stretch and pressure receptors in a variety of body. Wind turbine syndrome, since being coined by dr nina pierpont, the us pediatrician and phd graduate, has been commented on from all angles, pro and con one quote that i remember hearing some years ago, felt true at the time, and i feel is even more relevant now is. In 2009, pierpont selfpublished the book wind turbine syndrome, which included case studies of people who reportedly got sick as a result of their proximity to wind farms. Hit play button below, or click here to view or download as a 151mb mp4 file. Her book, reference 1, is an excellent resource regarding health effects wind turbine generated wts on the vestibular system. Health effect of wind turbines sciencebased medicine. Wind turbine syndrome future trends viessmann x the. Wind turbine syndrome some people have reported adverse symptoms which they have attributed to noise from wind turbines table i. The core of the book is 66 pages of ingeniously laid out tables wherein the author presents her clinical case histories. Chapman has found an ally in fiona crichton, from the department of psychological medicine at the university of auckland, and together they published the 2017 book wind turbine syndrome.
Physical risks associated with the production of wind energy. Pierpont was the first to describe wind turbine syndrome. The dubious science of windturbine syndrome the atlantic. A communicated disease, simon chapman and fiona crichton explore the claims and tactics of the antiwindfarm movement, examine the scientific evidence, and consider how best to. The most plausible health concern from proximity to wind turbines is that their noise can disturb sleep. Nina pierpont was a longterm campaigner against wind farms near her home who conducted a minor and very poorly constructed health survey. Infrasound and low frequency noise from wind turbines. One doctors quest to sound the alarm on wind turbine syndrome. The case definition proposed for wind turbine syndrome lists three criteria which can be used to identify people whose health has been affected by a wind turbine. New yorkbased pediatrician nina pierpont argues in her book, wind turbine syndrome, that turbines may produce sounds that can affect the mood of people nearby or cause physiological problems like insomnia, vertigo, headaches and nausea.
The distribution of recorded events, however, correlates with media coverage of wind farm syndrome. Of 51 wind farms studied, he states that for 33 of them no health complaints were made. Nina pierpont, here seen just moments before rogue turbine blades got tangled in her perm. Wind turbine syndrome and vibroacoustic disease wind. Other wind turbine syndrome effects noted include initial popping of ears followed by, then tinnitis ringing in the ears and a lessened ability to hear with background noise. I will not be discussing it further in this overview. Last year, a doctor at harvard medical school diagnosed sue hobart with wind turbine syndrome, an illness so mysterious that is not even recognized by. This survey was the basis for her selfpublished book which coined the phrase, wind turbine syndrome. Denmark is one of the world biggest producers of wind energy. A report on a natural experiment nina pierpont isbn. Wind turbine syndrome sufferers in cape cod sue daily. Her reputation as an authority on wind turbine syndrome is a 2009 selfpublished book containing descriptions of the health problems of just 10 families 38 people, 21 adults in five different. Such concern, as well as a dramatic amplification of symptom reports, coincided with the promotion in 2009 of the selfpublished book wind turbine syndromea natural experiment, also available and summarized on the internet.
Live within 5 km of a wind turbine, have experienced an altered health status since their exposure to it. The growing list of symptoms reportedly caused by infrasound arguably culminated in the 2009 publication wind turbine syndrome. Wind turbine syndrome sydney escholarship repository. Since publishing the book in late 2009, pierpont has heard from people around the world who are discovering that wind turbine syndrome is not confined to. Wind turbine syndrome and vibroacoustic disease wind wise. This syndrome is widely referenced by people campaigning against wind turbines. The book the wind turbine syndrome by pierpoint pierpoint 2009 argues that wind turbine noise can cause a variety of serious symptoms. In his 1973 book supernature, the scientist and adventurer lyall watson. My new book with fiona crichton, wind turbine syndrome.
Oct 21, 20 in 2009, pierpont selfpublished the book wind turbine syndrome, which included case studies of people who reportedly got sick as a result of their proximity to wind farms. Wind turbine syndrome the international tinnitus journal. Nina pierpont describes a condition called wind turbine syndrome in which wind farms pose actual health risks to nearby residents. Wind turbine syndrome a report on a natural experiment a book by nina pierpont. Nina pierponts wind turbine syndrome a real medical. A report on a natural experiment, by nina pierpont. Anxiety over windturbine syndrome stems from a decadesold. Wind energy is a multibillion dollar a year industry. This is an eyeopening account of the rise of the antiwindfarm movement, and a timely call for a more evidencebased approach. The newspaper said that research to be published later this year by an american doctor has identified a new health risk. The sickening truth about wind farm syndrome new scientist.
The book portrays infrasound produced by wind turbines as a threat to health, and explicitly sets out the physical. Pierpont makes a convincing argument based on information from personnel affected by wind turbines, that this issue has not been adequately studied to date. Nina pierpont, a pediatrician and population biologist in malone, new york, has announced the publication of her book length study wind turbine syndrome. Feb 21, 2020 my new book with fiona crichton, wind turbine syndrome. The incidence of wind turbine syndrome in countries that dont speak english is low, simon chapman says. Jun 03, 2018 3 wind turbine syndrome from a blog named on the www,windturbinesyndrome dot com. The wind turbine syndrome has been a huge epidemic in various locations all around the world for several years, with no specific rhyme or reason for the frequent and scattered claims. Nov 28, 2017 my new book with fiona crichton, wind turbine syndrome. Possible psychological mechanisms for wind turbine. From what can be deduced, the evidence presented by pierpont is a series of case studies and a small number at. A communicated disease, which can be downloaded for free online. Its not what your doctor knows that will kill you, its what heshe doesnt know. That, along with other data, suggests that its a disease communicated when wind farm. The study relies on interviews with 38 individuals from ten families living near wind turbines.
Since publishing the book in late 2009, pierpont has heard from people around the world who are discovering that wind turbine syndrome is not confined to living in the shadow of industrial wind turbines. Blowing away fears that wind turbines cause disease. Wind turbine syndrome and wind farm syndrome are terms for adverse human health effects that have been ascribed to the proximity of wind turbines. Maybe the wind turbine syndrome campaigners do believe they are in the midst of a classic scientific revolution like the internal radiation risk debate but, if so, they have a lot of catching up. The research works presented in this book are divided into three main groups. A communicated disease, simon chapman and fiona crichton explore the claims and tactics of the antiwindfarm movement, examine the scientific evidence, and consider how best to respond to antiwindfarm arguments.
There are also more subtle health risks of wind farming. The term wind turbine syndrome was coined in a recently selfpublished book, which hypothesized that a multitude of symptoms such as headache and dizziness resulted from wind turbines generating. Chronic sleep disturbance is a clear health risk, and so if this is true it would inform minimum safe distances between wind turbines and residential areas. The area of wind energy is a rapidly evolving field and an intensive research and development has taken place in the last few years. But importantly also acute symptoms, that according to australias high priestess of wind turbine syndrome, sarah laurie, an unregistered doctor, can commence within 20 minutes of exposure. Aug 19, 2019 the term wind turbine syndrome was coined by a canadian paediatrician named nina pierpont, who published a book under that title in 2009. Proponents have claimed that these effects include, congenital abnormality, cancer, and death. As to whether or not noise from wind farms can harm people and wildlife, the jury is still out. Oct 03, 2012 but importantly also acute symptoms, that according to australias high priestess of wind turbine syndrome, sarah laurie, an unregistered doctor, can commence within 20 minutes of exposure. Oct 21, 20 last year, a doctor at harvard medical school diagnosed sue hobart with wind turbine syndrome, an illness so mysterious that is not even recognized by the centers for disease control and prevention. Jun 19, 2017 the growing list of symptoms reportedly caused by infrasound arguably culminated in the 2009 publication wind turbine syndrome. Wind turbine syndrome, i propose, is mediated by the vestibular system by disturbed sensory input to eyes, inner.
Children could exhibit a lessened ability to distinguish between similar consonants confusing t and k and w and l. Nov 11, 2014 the use of an illness label wind turbine syndrome, along with a widely publicized and explicated list of syndrome symptoms, not only creates the impression that there is a risk that those living near wind turbines will develop a recognized medical condition, but also creates a comprehensive idea of expected symptoms. The book is titled wind turbine syndrome and was written by nina pierpont. Wind turbine syndrome sufferers in cape cod sue mail online.
How to catch wind turbine syndrome by hearing about it. Physical risks associated with the production of wind. Wind turbine syndrome gained traction in 2009 when dr. Pierpont with her new book and navigation added by her website. When fiona crichton and i wrote our 2017 book wind turbine syndrome. Living too close to wind turbines can cause heart disease, tinnitus, vertigo, panic attacks, migraines and sleep deprivation, the independent on sunday reported. This books main focus is on the claims that wind turbines are the direct cause of a number of short and longterm health problems. Therefore, this book aims to provide an uptodate comprehensive overview of the current status in the field to the research community. There have been signs of adverse effects of wind turbines on nearby farm animals. What is wind turbine syndrome this purported syndrome originall. Pierponts study contained many of the symptoms now associated with wind turbines, but her research was criticized for its methods. The link between health complaints and wind turbines. Pierponts book, wind turbine syndrome, is a deeply flawed and vastly overinflated work that is causing much more harm than any good it might be attempting to achieve.
292 1063 134 1063 577 1441 1105 1003 327 1236 779 517 288 201 208 107 595 403 965 670 276 723 885 994 684 1205 636 190 617 846 795 254 339 651 288 1157 676 65 835